Toyota BZ Forum banner

Ultimate EV Driving Machine (bz4x) Needs Ultimate Tires (Michelin)

1 reading
547 views 17 replies 4 participants last post by  Reckless  
#1 · (Edited)
I consider EV tires to be the Achilles heel of EVs. Need to go back to performance tires and take the hit on range.
Image


In my quest to make the Ultimate EV Driving Machine (2024 bz4x xle) perform at its peak I find the need to upgrade tires. The oem Bridgestone Turanzas are basically a compliance tire meant for leasees to replace after 25k miles. It wasn't meant to be driven in highway construction or at high speeds for long periods. I need a performance tire even though in my eyes I am not a performance driver. Performance drivers drive it like they stole it, I only drive fast not furious 🏎.

I placed an order for Michelin Defender 2 in hopes that I get my 80k mile warranty and it is better suited for sustained 80-100mph highway driving due to its compound staying cool under long speed runs. I considered Michelin Primacy Tour A/S and Michelin Cross Climate 3s very heavily. Cross Climate3 sounds like the all the season champion being released in few months but for repeated highspeed driving would transmit too much vibration. Primacy Tour A/S are supposed to be the most luxury tire but would lose alot of treadlife under highway speeds which is what I like to joy ride at.

Dealer told me Toyota recommends Yokohama but I heard they get unruly prematurely and have half the tread life to save $40. Chatgpt says estimated life of Defender 2 is 50k miles so I expect I will be going through these tires every other year. Looking forward to the day when they find a way to make tires last 100,000 miles. My BFG KO2 DTs (Different Tread) lasted over 150k miles when I sold my land cruiser but they were getting a bit extra firm on the road. The normal KO2s would only last 35-40k miles before losing big chunks of nubs.

Stock Bridgestones Turanzas had a serious hydroplaning issue. I noticed that all these EV tires give up an important performance characteristic in order to have lower rolling resistance to increase range. Since I mostly drive local and need maximum 70 mile range daily (currently) I don't mind taking a hit on the range. I expect it will be 25 mile reduction which should hopefully leave me 190 miles with AC at 100%, probably 140 miles with heat in winter. My Home DC charger is nearly hooked up so hopefully I can charge to full in 30 minutes (I usually use 40% battery going back and forth across chicago north side, west side, south side, suburbs).

I love EVs but can't stand changing tires every year and would rather lose minor ride quality and ev range to get a longer lasting tire as long as I get much better road manners/performance. I don't see many EV enthusiasts sharing my philosophy so I thought I'd post to better understand why others don't share my optimism. EVs are great if they have same road manners as ICE vehicles. I switched my E-Transit tires from Continentals to Michelin Aegis tires. The oem continentals did not last 7k miles from new, 2 rear tires were bald when I bought mine used. I took a minor hit on range since the Michelins were extra grippy but in snow they performed better than a drift car. I did lose highway wind protection the continentals did better but they were not a dedicated EV tire just a compliance tire for Ford Vans and had some special technology to keep wheels more planted (high roof vans are affected by wind alot, luckily I bought a medium roof).

I grew up on BMWs and Mercedes and Michelins were always what they came with. I understand Toyota has a much different clientele and much lighter weight vehicles where Michelins are not necessarily king. I had bad luck with Pirelli's in the past which makes me doubt their durability. My honda friends were always Yoko fans but I don't believe they make long lasting tires. Some of the other european brands I don't have as much experience with and prefer not wasting money on expensive tires unless it brings a serious performance upgrade.

I think tires are the single biggest upgrade possible on EVs and even though I like to follow Toyota's advice I just don't see how any grand touring tire will last that wasn't specifically made for long tread life (standard touring tire).
 
#2 ·
I found my tires half price which should run $0.007 per mile. The way I am approaching this my goal is to be 1 cent/mi for maintenance, 1 cent/mi for power (hourly pricing with solar), 8 cent/mi for insurance to reach my goal of $0.10 per mile. Insurance costs lessen with more mileage driven annually (still a huge pain in my eyes). $2500 / year is higher than I like with most of the cost being insurance.
 
#3 ·
Got them installed today and they are definitely much better than the oem bridgestone turanzas that came with the vehicle. I think my biggest problem with the OEM turanzas were they wore unevenly so road felt more rough both smooth pavement and rough. Even hurt my back with all the swaying going across town.

Officially this is the absolute BEST upgrade one can make to bz4x. Totally changes character, ride, abilities of the vehicle. There are pluses and minuses.

Pros:
Ride is very smooth
Confidence inspiring
Much more traction dry/wet/snow
100k mile Tread life with no noticeable loss in traction/capabilities
Quiet Tire
Able to do high speed maneuvers easier (not a race car) as it hugs the road on curves

Negatives:
Not being Low Rolling Resistance means before when I drive 70mph it feels like how it felt doing 100mph in oem tire. Now at 50mph it feels like 70mph old tire even though there is no noticeable audible difference to our ears (it is quieter than when the bridgestones got some miles on them).

I only notice 1% drop in first 50 miles on energy meter. I am posting this for anyone else like me who was confused why they are driving a highly capable vehicle but not getting proper performance. I was confused and spent alot of unnecessary time trying to figure this out. For others it was probably a very simple conclusion. For me, I wish I had dumped the original tires first day and not wasted my time with them at all, it is a small regret for me.


There was another choice that I am very curious about called Michelin Primacy Tour AS. I didn't mind paying more for it and getting half the tread life BUT I need much more than 10% ride improvement. Especially at 80mph its closer to 5%.
 
#4 ·
I dumped my Turanzas at 31K even though they still had 7/32 tread left. They were getting noisy, and water traction had degraded. I decided to go with the Bridgestone Alenza AS Ultra which have an 80K warranty. Not designed specifically for EVs but I figured a harder tire (indicative of the higher mileage warranty) would have less rolling resistance than a lower tread warranty soft tire. I have not noticed any degradation in range.
 
#5 ·
Did you lose any feeling when driving fast but feeling car moving slow? Like rubber rolling super smooth so 100mph feels like you are driving 50mph. That's my only gripe with non EV tires, super excellent traction and tread life but giving up that awesome feeling of gliding on the road. I don't want 20k miles out of tires but love that feeling. I might go to 50k to get it but hate the hassle of mounting and buying tires and more importantly the feeling when I run over some rough terrain that I chewed up my tires.
 
#7 ·
Still breaking them in so its early to tell. First 1000 miles are different than the rest supposedly. But overall ride quality is really good, only main notable difference is the lack of low rolling resistance. It is something I do miss but initially was in the impression that long life low rolling resistance tires don't exist. I think Pirelli makes something with a long warranty (in past pirellis were very famous for not lasting). In some ways removing low rolling resistance has helped me stop flying 30-50 mph over the speed limit everywhere but car does feel much more planted now. Tires do feel heavier too, but they have the most durable tread ever. Makes it like butter running over obstacles/pot holes which is common in chicago. I do have the psi 5 psi higher as winter is coming soon and expect air to leak out. Ride was extra jarring first night but it is settling as each day continues because of the extra firm rubber. It does change the character of the car moving from low rolling resistance to regular tires. It feels like an awesome winter tire how heavy/planted it feels. I also like not sweating running over bumps/rough terrain. It reminds me of my first car 1993 BMW 3 series with 16" michelin sport tires.
 
#9 ·
Unfortunately my Toyota dealer didn't have this. 10 years ago they would charge $100 for this at a Mercedes Dealer.
 
#11 ·
Nitrogen is a joke. Regular air is over 70% nitrogen as it is. Any mechanic or honest tire shop will tell you it's waste. Fine in aircraft tires or race tires. In a passenger car all it gives you is fancy green valve stem caps and a royal PIA anytime you want to add air
 
#13 ·
FYI 5 psi is very noticable ride quality difference on this tire. I think the very high rubber wear rating affects it more than my softer Michelin tires in past.

I had nitrogen on Mercedes with super low profile tires which helped. Not sure if it will be as needed on this but will try to find nitrogen if air leaks out. What I notice is air pressure changes as tires warm up.
 
#14 ·
After 1 week tires feel very nice especially on the construction and uneven pavement. Highly recommended soo far. It did take a week or so to break in. Don't bother over inflating tires. For me defender 2 shine on roads with high friction, sound does get into cabin slightly but when you are driving over super rough surfaces you want to know the damage your tires are taking. I think thats why I went through oem tires extra fast as all the major highways near me are under heavy 5 year construction. But even if it weren't after seeing how LRR tires get chewed up I wouldn't want them. I love how they glide like a condor but it's a very weak rubber, not a super rubber designed for beatings. I don't see the formula working to have no friction and tires handling abuse and longevity along with poor weather handling.

We had heavy rain for short moments yesterday and tire didn't lift at all, very planted. I am a Michelin fan so I am slightly biased. In the end I seek the ultimate tires regardless of brand but each person has different needs and driving styles. I don't like having to worry about the abuse my tires take.
 
#16 ·
After having 10-15 high end germans my butt is like niki lauda, I can sense the car underneath me. I was even debating today whether I would have been happier in mercedes eqs vs bz4x as they are the same price. I like toyota engineering but miss mercedes suspensions, mostly for my back. I don't like my elderly parents feeling any potholes on the road as they get easily affected. Chicago has been terrible, potholes are getting bigger and we are heading to winter season. Traffic seems to be coming down with the whole attack on civilians, no one feels like going out and being harassed by military police.
It's really a catch 22, a quality tire will not give the uber soft cushy ride that LRR tires give. One is better for offroading and the other for perfectly flat roads. Normally highway tires are the best when highways are like the autobahn but chicago's potholes are infamous, second to NYC. I once lost an entire car in a sinkhole.
 
#17 ·
I can. When I switched the ones on our RAV from the factory rubber at 26k (which sounded like a set of garbage truck tires) to the Michelin Cross Climate 2. The difference was night and day. the CC2 was nearly silent, road outstanding, steering response is incredible with them. There is everything to like except one glaring issue for an electrified vehicle. They REALLY hurt the economy and the range. Turned a 50+ mpg vehicle to an upper 30s to low 40s. They REALLY suck for economy. I'd never recommend to anyone with a full electric.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reckless
#18 · (Edited)
Yeah CC2s are not as good on electric vehicles as they have too much traction and a different sidewall pattern that isnt tuned for evs. Defender 2s are better from what I understood. I put Michelin cross climate aigilis on my ford etransit van, different than CC2. Both tires lost less than 5-10 miles of range from OEM but much, much better traction and ride feel. The aigils tires were exceptional on the ford but I haul 3000lbs + tow.

I have been paying closer attention on my bz4x and I haven't seen a massive hit in energy consumption but there are days I drive hard and fast. Other days slow and easy. Based on driving style my consumption has been commiserate. I did see much higher numbers in beginning which made no sense to me, when I had overfilled the tires. But it made ride bumpy and I think was more breaking in than higher pressure. Even when I am racing 90 mph I haven't seen anything less than 2.7kw on trip meter but tires seem harder to spin out because of more friction. Cold nights has just started so I will know more soon as I run heater. My range figures still show 232 miles which is same after 2 weeks of owning bz4x at 100%. Driven 600 miles on michelins so far.